Missing Oxford comma changes court ruling - WLOX.com - The News for South Mississippi

Missing Oxford comma changes court ruling

A State law's confusing grammar may win 75 drivers $10 million in overtime pay. (Source: Pixabay) A State law's confusing grammar may win 75 drivers $10 million in overtime pay. (Source: Pixabay)

(RNN) – Majoring in English may not come with promising career prospects, but that doesn’t mean having good grammar can’t save a little cash.

In one of the nerdiest cases in history, an appeals court in Maine ruled that a group of 75 dairy drivers were owed $10 million in overtime pay because of a missing Oxford comma.

“For want of a comma, we have this case,” Judge David Barron wrote in his decision. “… As it happens, there is no serial comma to be found in the exemption’s list of activities, thus leading to this dispute over whether the drivers fall within the exemption from the overtime law or not.”

The dispute centers on a state law that says certain activities do not qualify for overtime pay.

The canning, processing, preserving, freezing, drying, marketing, storing, packing for shipment or distribution of:

(1) Agricultural produce;
(2) Meat and fish products; and
(3) Perishable foods.

The lack of a comma between “packing for shipment” and “or distribution” is the distinction. A serial comma, or Oxford comma, is used before the penultimate item in a list to add clarity. The drivers contend that "packing for shipment or distribution" is one exempt item, not two separate items. Because they only work in distribution, they say they're entitled to overtime pay.

The case is another battle in the longstanding war between English grammarians.

For example, the sentence “I love my friends, John and Mary” is a little unclear without the serial comma. Are John and Mary the names of the writer’s friends? Or does the writer mean to say he or she loves three separate entities?

To be fair, the Oxford comma can also overcomplicate poorly written sentences. Take the sentence “I met with John, the lawyer, and Simon.” It’s unclear if John is a lawyer or if the lawyer is a third item in the list.

The 75 drivers probably don’t care about any of that nerdy stuff. They just want a big check, and they’re one step closer to getting one. 

The appeals court decision overturned an earlier district court decision. According to the Bangor Daily News, the court case will likely go on before a final decision is made.

But this early ruling is one small step for the drivers, and one giant leap for Oxford comma enthusiast everywhere.

Copyright 2017 Raycom News Network. All rights reserved.

  • NEWSMore>>

  • Alberto shifts further east but Mississippi isn't in the clear just yet

    Alberto shifts further east but Mississippi isn't in the clear just yet

    Saturday, May 26 2018 5:34 PM EDT2018-05-26 21:34:13 GMT

    Alberto is forecast to become a fully tropical storm Saturday and then will move into the Gulf of Mexico this weekend.

    More >>

    Alberto is forecast to become a fully tropical storm Saturday and then will move into the Gulf of Mexico this weekend.

    More >>
  • Campers told to vacate Gulf Islands National Seashore ahead of Alberto

    Campers told to vacate Gulf Islands National Seashore ahead of Alberto

    Saturday, May 26 2018 2:59 PM EDT2018-05-26 18:59:51 GMT
    Campers at Gulf Islands National Seashore were told to vacate Saturday due to potential bad weather from Alberto (photo source: WLOX)Campers at Gulf Islands National Seashore were told to vacate Saturday due to potential bad weather from Alberto (photo source: WLOX)
    Campers at Gulf Islands National Seashore were told to vacate Saturday due to potential bad weather from Alberto (photo source: WLOX)Campers at Gulf Islands National Seashore were told to vacate Saturday due to potential bad weather from Alberto (photo source: WLOX)

    Gulf Islands National Seashore is shutting down ahead of any potential thunderstorms associated with Alberto.

    More >>

    Gulf Islands National Seashore is shutting down ahead of any potential thunderstorms associated with Alberto.

    More >>
  • TRAFFIC ALERT: Popps Ferry Bridge back open

    TRAFFIC ALERT: Popps Ferry Bridge back open

    Saturday, May 26 2018 2:31 PM EDT2018-05-26 18:31:56 GMT
    Popps Ferry Bridge is at a standstill due to a malfunction with the crossing arms. (Source: File)Popps Ferry Bridge is at a standstill due to a malfunction with the crossing arms. (Source: File)

    Traffic is at standstill right now on the Popps Ferry Bridge in Biloxi. Authorities say the crossing bars at the bridge's span are stuck in the down position, preventing traffic from flowing. 

    More >>

    Traffic is at standstill right now on the Popps Ferry Bridge in Biloxi. Authorities say the crossing bars at the bridge's span are stuck in the down position, preventing traffic from flowing. 

    More >>
Powered by Frankly