Photographer wages potential legal battle with Wikimedia over mo - WLOX.com - The News for South Mississippi

Photographer wages potential legal battle with Wikimedia over monkey's selfie

A British photographer and Wikimedia could be facing a legal battle over whether he or a monkey own the rights to a photograph that’s been seen across the internet. (Source: Wikimedia Commons screenshot) A British photographer and Wikimedia could be facing a legal battle over whether he or a monkey own the rights to a photograph that’s been seen across the internet. (Source: Wikimedia Commons screenshot)

(RNN) – A British photographer is battling Wikimedia for the use of photos the open-source website says belong to the public domain of the monkey that took them.

Nature photographer David Slater told the British newspaper The Telegraph on Wednesday that during his 2011 trip to Indonesia, a crested black macaque stole his equipment and “took hundreds of selfies.”

Most of the photos, Slater said, are blurry, but two of them have made it to Wikimedia Commons. The web collection, owned by Wikimedia, holds 22,309,460 “freely usable media files to which anyone can contribute,” the website says.

The images have been posted across the internet since being posted to Wikimedia Commons. The site told Slater that because the macaca took the photos, they belong to the monkey and are otherwise public domain.

“If the monkey took it, it owns copyright, not me, that’s their basic argument. What they don’t realize is that it needs a court to decide that,” Slater told The Telegraph.

The photographer said use of the image has cost him a lot of money, and The Telegraph reports that Slater faces a 10,000 euro, or $13,383.95, legal bill to fight Wikimedia in court.

Slater petitioned Wikimedia, nominating the images to be deleted from its archives on Thursday. The reason, Slater said, is “Wikimedia is displaying it unlawfully.”

Wikimedia has classified the image as public domain, “because as the work of a non-human, it has no human author in whom copyright is vested.”

For its part, Wikimedia said in a transparency report Wednesday that no one, including the macaca, owns the image, thus its place in the public domain – and just because Slater owns the camera the photos were taken on doesn't mean the image is his.

The editors, throughout the conversation, are split on its decision, but the photos remain on Wikimedia Commons website.

One commenter wrote: “The monkey did not buy the camera and travel to a foreign country to take pictures. This isn't some funny random camera phone, Facebook photo someone found on the internet and appropriated. This guy takes photographs for a living. These photographs are his work.”

Follow me on Twitter @TanitaG_RNN.

Copyright 2014 Raycom News Network. All rights reserved.

  • Who owns the rights to the monkey selfie?

  • Thank you for participating in our poll. Here are the results so far:

    No one - the monkey took them.
    22%
    46 votes
    The photographer - they are his images on his camera.
    78%
    163 votes
  • NEWSMore>>

  • VIDEO: One in custody after Gulfport chase

    VIDEO: One in custody after Gulfport chase

    Monday, July 24 2017 8:25 PM EDT2017-07-25 00:25:36 GMT
    (Photo source: Chuck Coats)(Photo source: Chuck Coats)

    One person is in custody after a chase through Gulfport and parts of Harrison County.

    More >>

    One person is in custody after a chase through Gulfport and parts of Harrison County.

    More >>
  • Intoxicated driver who injured Bethanie Jones pleads guilty

    Intoxicated driver who injured Bethanie Jones pleads guilty

    Monday, July 24 2017 8:05 PM EDT2017-07-25 00:05:14 GMT
    Bethanie Jones, 27, was severely injured in a car accident on Popps Ferry Road Bridge (Image Source: WLOX News)Bethanie Jones, 27, was severely injured in a car accident on Popps Ferry Road Bridge (Image Source: WLOX News)

    Two years ago, Bethanie Jones was involved in a crash on the Popp’s Ferry Bridge that would change her life. Monday, the driver that hit her pleaded guilty to DUI causing death or disfigurement.

    More >>

    Two years ago, Bethanie Jones was involved in a crash on the Popp’s Ferry Bridge that would change her life. Monday, the driver that hit her pleaded guilty to DUI causing death or disfigurement.

    More >>
  • Matt Luke introduced as Ole Miss interim head coach

    Matt Luke introduced as Ole Miss interim head coach

    Monday, July 24 2017 7:39 PM EDT2017-07-24 23:39:47 GMT
    WLBTWLBT
    14 years as part of the Ole Miss football program as a coach or player has prepared Matt Luke for this opportunity. Admittedly it doesn't come under the circumstances he might've envisioned. But with a Rebel bloodline that runs 3 generations deep, the position fulfills a lifelong dream. "I can truly tell y'all today that this is my dream job," Luke said Monday at his first press conference as Ole Miss interim head coach. "It's a job that I've been preparing my whole li...More >>
    14 years as part of the Ole Miss football program as a coach or player has prepared Matt Luke for this opportunity. Admittedly it doesn't come under the circumstances he might've envisioned. But with a Rebel bloodline that runs 3 generations deep, the position fulfills a lifelong dream. "I can truly tell y'all today that this is my dream job," Luke said Monday at his first press conference as Ole Miss interim head coach. "It's a job that I've been preparing my whole li...More >>
Powered by Frankly